On July 19, the world lost a visionary teacher, scholar, and beloved friend: Joanna Macy (1929-2025). A guiding light in systems thinking, deep ecology, and Buddhist philosophy, Joanna touched countless lives with her intellect, her heart, and her unwavering commitment to life on Earth.
On Aug. 15, 2025, Mexico, Guatemala, and Belize formalized an agreement to create a tri-national reserve across 5.7 million hectares of the Mayan rainforest—a bold alliance in safeguarding biodiversity, indigenous wisdom, and ecological resilience. This is, in spirit and scale, the kind of regenerative response Joanna championed—a communal turn toward interconnection, care, and cosmic-scale healing.
In sharp contrast, the Dana Reserve mega-development in Nipomo, California, casts a long shadow of ecological disregard. Approved in April 2024, this 288-acre housing project includes up to 1,400 residential units, commercial zones, parks, and more—all at the expense of a rare and irreplaceable woodland ecosystem. Lawsuits from the Nipomo Action Committee and the California Native Plant Society resulted in a settlement that reduces development by approximately 229 units (about 16 percent smaller), halves affordable housing from 156 to 78 units, and protects additional oak trees and manzanita plants. The agreement also includes off-site habitat mitigation.
Critics see this as a partial concession that still prioritizes development over preservation, even as it acknowledges the urgency of ecological responsibility.
Local naturalists warn that the loss is not only about trees; it’s the disappearance of complex habitat networks that cannot be re-created in our lifetimes.
Developers propose planting 1,500 to 3,000 new oak trees on-site and conserving up to 14,000 oaks on a 400-acre off-site parcel. This effort, while seemingly substantial, still fails to account for:
• Temporal inequity: Mature trees take decades—centuries—to mature.
• Different habitat context: Off-site parcels may not contain the same sensitive species or ecological conditions as the original site—meaning true habitat replacement is impossible.
Residents are grieving—not just the loss of trees, but a loss of identity, history, and place.
These oak woodlands symbolize more than ecology—they are legacies etched into ground that sustained generations, including the Chumash people, and now face irreparable removal.
The Great Mayan Forest Corridor is regenerative, collaborative, and indigenous-inclusive. It preserves an ancient forest and biodiversity, embodies deep belonging and reciprocity, and is aligned with Joanna Macy’s vision. The conservation is rooted in healing and systemic change.
The Dana Reserve is driven by growth, fragments the community, and is contested. It will result in massive deforestation and ecosystem destabilization, erases local identity and natural heritage, and is not aligned with Joanna’s vision.
K. Rosa
Nipomo
The post Choosing our Earth appeared first on Santa Maria Sun.